BLOG #11: HYSTERECTOMY…WHEN AND WHY?

This article addresses hysterectomy in common benign (not cancerous) disorders, with emphasis on the role of the procedure in endometriosis.

uterus_xs_27232026Technically speaking, the surgical treatment of  endometriosis rarely requires removal of the uterus (see prior article on ‘the Gold Standard‘). Lesions of ‘endo’ are less common on the uterus, and superficial (serosal) uterine endometriosis can be excised without removing the uterus itself. The primary objective of surgical treatment should be the complete excision of each and every endometriosis lesion. The secondary objectives are the removal of adhesions and restoration of normal anatomy if at all possible (predicated on the degree of irreversible destructive change already present).

BUT…

The majority of patients are even more interested in pain relief and quality of life than the technicalities of the surgical procedure. Each patient has a unique clinical expression of her disease. This clinical picture is made up of how she feels, where she hurts and when, and her doctor’s observations and examination results. Special tests (like ultrasound, CT and MRI scans, etc.) may add to this picture.

If the ‘gold standard’ surgical treatment of Laparoscopic Excision (LAPEX) is performed and all endo is removed, but the clinical expression of her surgically treated disease remains a problem (despite the successful removal of all endometriosis), the treatment is a failure in the mind of the patient.

In my experience, the overall success of LAPEX in reversing the clinical picture of a patient’s endo is about 80%. This figure is based on our patient follow-up efforts regarding quality of life, any ongoing pain issues, and the frequency and outcomes of any subsequent surgical procedures for persistent pain.

WHEN IS HYSTERECTOMY OFFERED?

In my practice, the patient has always made the decision herself to have the uterus surgically removed, usually after my consultation and often additional  consultations. In these patients, I have advised them to consider hysterectomy, because there is evidence that they have additional uterine disease (e.g. adenomyosis) that is part of their clinical picture. Although we may have removed their endo prior to hysterectomy, we have not removed all of their sources of pain. Here are a few examples:

  • Adhesion Recurrence: in advanced stage patients, the surgical removal of all endo can leave many injured areas that must heal. The ultimate objective is that each treated area heals completely and independently (i.e not joined to any other structure). The greater the number and size of the areas treated, the more likely it is that tissues will be conjoined in the healing process. The recurrence or new formation of adhesions can cause pain very similar to the pain caused by the endo that we have removed. If these adhesions significantly involve the uterus, repeat surgery may be required for pain relief (about 25% of my stage 4 patients), and of this 25%, a few will choose to have the uterus removed so that it can no longer be encumbered by adhesions.
  • Adenomyosis: some patients have secondary problems in addition to endometriosis, such as adenomyosis. From Latin, this term literally means ‘gland in muscle’. If endometrial glands are present in the uterine wall interspersed amongst the smooth muscle fibers normally found in that area, it is called ‘adenomyosis’. If you look at the holes in a common sea sponge, you get a visual idea of what I am referring to.  Adenomyosis can cause severe pelvic pain and uterine cramping. Sometimes the degree of pain is intolerable, and the patient may choose hysterectomy. I will blog more about adenomyosis in greater detail in the future, so stay tuned.
  • Fibroids=Leiomyomata Uteri: fibroid tumors (usually benign growths of encapsulated muscle in the uterine wall) are typically treated conservatively, but recurrence after conservative treatments (hormone suppression, uterine embolization, myomectomy, etc.) or very large fibroids may require a hysterectomy. This of course can be a problem independent of endo, but I have treated endometriosis and performed a hysterectomy coincidentally at my patient’s request on a few occasions.

There are a few other indications for the consideration of hysterectomy for benign disorders, but this gives you the general idea.

FINALLY…

It is critically important to point out that hysterectomy does not cure endometriosis. Each lesion of the disease must also be removed. I have operated on literally dozens of patients who have not only had their uterus removed but also one or both ovaries, only to have the untreated areas of endometriosis that were left behind previously continue to cause pain and ultimately require another surgery to remove the remaining disease.

Hysterectomy may be an option for an indivdual, considering the unique nature of her personal case, after careful and informed discussions with her physician. Stay tuned for the next blog!

Disclaimer: any and all material(s) presented herein are offered for informational purposes only. Such material is not intended to offer or replace medical advice offered by your personal physicians or healthcare professionals. No information herein should be considered as party to any doctor/patient relationship. All contents herein are © copyright by Robert B. Albee, Jr., MD except where otherwise explicitly noted. All rights reserved. This material may not be reproduced or utilized in any form, including electronic or mechanical, photocopying, recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system except for personal or teaching use with prior permission. Thank you.

Blog #10: Endometriosis & Pain

pain (2)

We might think that endometriosis (‘endo’) pain would be something that every sufferer could understand in the same way. Unfortunately, this is not the case. Endo pain is multi-factorial and different for each patient. So, when a person says, ‘I am experiencing pain from my endometriosis’, other sufferers might assume that they know exactly what is being experienced. The truth is that pain from endo is often unique to the individual experiencing it.

One undesirable result of associating one specific group of symptoms with the diagnosis of endo is that this can lead to a delayed diagnosis – or no diagnosis at all, thus prolonging suffering and increasing the likelihood of disease advancement.

The factors influencing the type of pain a patient experiences include:

  • The location of the endometriosis lesion(s)
  • The amount of inflammation around the lesion and the blood supply to it
  • The proximity of the lesion(s) to local nerve supply
  • The organs affected by endo (peritoneum, fallopian tube, ovary, bladder wall, bowel wall, ureteral wall, vaginal wall, etc.
  • The presence of adhesions in the area
  • The presence or absence of prior pain in the same area
  • The concomitant use of medication including but not limited to:
    • Anti-inflammatory agents
    • Narcotic agents
    • Muscle relaxants
    • Seratonin modulating drugs
    • Ovulation suppressing medications
  • Physical activity
  • Application of heat and/or cold
  • Any practical or psychological benefit (whether the patient is aware of it or not) that the patient receives by way of ‘being in pain’
  • Anger and resentment that results in muscle tension

It is a daunting task to try to point out every type and location of pain that endo sufferers might feel and why it occurs in the way that it does, but I would like to try to describe some of them. If your specific situation does not seem to be adequately covered, send me an email and I will try to cover it as I have an opportunity.

TYPES OF PAIN

CHRONIC ACHE: See above example. I often think of nerve involvement or internal pressure when I hear this complaint.

COLICKY:  This pain is a slowly building and then residing pain. It is often associated with lesions on/in/or close to the wall of the intestine. As the bowel wall dilates to allow passage of gas/liquid/solid material, the lesion is variably impacted.

MENSTRUAL: Abnormal menstrual bleeding, clotting and cramping, etc. can be associated with several different causes. Endo is one of them. We will discuss other causes for difficult menstrual periods at a future time. Here it is important to know that other diagnoses should be considered as well as endo when trying to understand unusually difficult menses.

BLOATING: Usually means that for one reason or another, the transfer of gas/liquid/solid through the intestine is slowed and the bowel diameter is increasing. The patient is essentially ‘pregnant’ with a dilated intestine.

SHARP/KNIFE-LIKE/TEARING: May occur if blood is released into the abdominal cavity and irritates the peritoneum, or if muscle, containing lesions of endo, is stretched or moved. Sharp pain is also reported when any area of endo receives direct pressure such as the vaginal wall lesions during intercourse.

PAIN LOCATION

Pain occurring from above the knee to the mid chest still only covers about 95% of the locations that have been reported.

Pain location is certainly dependent on disease location and the nerves close by, but it is also dependent on the proximity of the lesion(s) to nearby organs and the impact of the lesion(s) on the natural function of the organ involved. For example:

A lesion at the top of the vaginal wall may not cause any pain in a resting situation, but may make sexual intercourse extremely painful, because intercourse puts direct pressure on the site of the lesion. A patient might say, “It only hurts when I have sex.”

Or, a lesion on the bowel wall in the area of the rectum may cause an ache when there is a need to have a bowel movement, and extreme pain (‘I faint every time I have to go to the bathroom’) as someone tries to have a bowel movement. Yet, after defecation, this individual may feel fine.

Or, a lesion on the surface of the ovary (or an endometrioma inside the ovary) may cause extreme pain around the time of ovulation. This person’s pain may gradually increase after menses and actually go away when the next menses finally starts (when the ovary returns to its resting size).

Or, a lesion in the posterior pelvis close to the local nerve supply may cause a chronic low back pain that never seems to go away.

Pain from ureteral involvement may mimic urinary obstruction symptoms, and pain from bowel wall lesions may cause distension of the entire abdomen.

The well-described scenario of painful menstrual cramps and backache is certainly very common and may even be associated with menstrual nausea and vomiting, but it is very important to understand the many other symptoms that may be caused by endo so that the diagnosis gets consideration.

INFLAMMATION

Inflammation is defined as ‘the reaction of tissues to injurious agents’ and ‘may be associated with redness, swelling, pain, tenderness, and heat.’ Inflammation commonly causes pain.

Endo lesions may have surrounding inflammation or they may not. Some lesions seem to be tolerated by the body without any surrounding reaction. We know that this is true because we can see at the time of surgery obvious differences in the surrounding tissue reaction when inflammation is present.

Endo lesions without inflammation may cause no pain at all. For example,  endo may be diagnosed by the surgeon at the time of an unrelated surgery (think appendectomy). When asked post-operatively, some have had no symptoms what-so-ever.

PROXIMITY TO LOCAL SENSORY NERVES

Sensory nerve supply is not uniformly distributed throughout the body and particularly the floor of the pelvis. One side of the body may actually be different than the other. Mesenteric fatty tissues have a different configuration of sensory nerves than the utero-sacral ligaments. As a result, lesions located far from nerve bundles may have little or no effect on pain.

ORGAN INVOLVEMENT WITH ENDO

Ovaries, fallopian tubes, intestinal walls, ureters, vaginal walls, and bladder walls are all vital organs that function independently in the lower abdomen and pelvis. When the function of one or more of these organs is impacted by the presence of endometriosis, it may cause pain. See above for examples of the different types of pain that might occur.

ADHESIONS

Adhesions are created when the body reacts to injury. They may be fine, filamentous webs, hard dense white bands, or glue-like attachments that extend from one structure to the other. Adhesions may form around areas of endo or occur after surgery to remove the disease. Whenever these attachments limit the free mobility of and organ, they are likely to cause pain.

A HISTORY OF PAIN IN THE SAME AREA

When someone has had severe pain in a specific area in the past, sensitivity in that area may increase. I do not understand the scientific reason for this to occur, but I believe it is real – not imagined.

USE OF CONCOMITTENT MEDICATION

First of all, I would like to make a plea for personal vigilance in the use of medication and supplements. In my experience, health care professionals and pharmacists do only a fair job of anticipating medication interaction. The best and safest way to add any medication is to first research it for yourself. This can be done online at various sites like https://www.webmd.com/interaction-checker/default.htm.

Narcotics, muscle relaxants, anti-inflammatories, and serotonin modulating drugs can all impact the pain a patient experiences at a given point in time. Because their mechanisms of action are different, healthcare professionals may use them independently or sometimes in combination. In each category, prolonged regular use of the drug may encourage a psychological dependence; therefore I advise extreme caution with regular professional re-evaluation when prolonged pain therapies are being used. Additionally, both narcotics and muscle relaxants may induce a physical addiction/dependence requiring medical attention.

Drugs that suppress ovulation may reduce pain by inhibiting the natural increase in ovarian size that occurs during the natural ovarian cycle. The secondary effect of minimizing estrogen/progesterone ups and downs may also reduce pain by reducing menstrual flow (or causing menstruation cessation altogether). We will talk about the mechanism of action of other drug therapies in a different blog.

HEAT & COLD

Heat tends to increase circulation to tissues and can be a great aid to healing; however, it may be associated with localized swelling in the tissues. This can be increase discomfort.

Cold tends to reduce blood supply and reduce swelling. It may also tend to relax tense muscles.

Alternating heat/cold therapies is a well-known method for enhancing healing and controlling pain, and is appropriate for endo patients.

See also my note about avoiding extreme heat on the abdominal wall. I have seen many cases of fat dystrophy from intense heat used because of disabling abdominal pain.

PHYSICAL ACTIVITY

As noted previously, physical activity may or may not increase pain. Movement of tissues containing lesions/cysts surrounded by inflammation often makes exercise uncomfortable. However, there is great individual variation and there are some who are able to exercise without pain.

It is rare that anyone needs to avoid exercise if it causes no pain (perhaps large ovarian cysts require caution), and in general, I think exercise when possible is a strong positive.

NEUROGENIC PAIN

Neurogenic pain is defined as pain due to dysfunction of the peripheral or central nervous system, in the absence of nociceptor (nerve terminal) stimulation by trauma or disease.

It is difficult to know how often neurogenic pain occurs in endo patients, but there are times when I suspect that this is the origin of pain. For example, I excise endo from a patient who has suffered for years secondary to misdiagnosis and ineffective treatments. She returns with the same pain that she has reported in the past. Yet, at a second-look Laparoscopy, there is no endo and there are no adhesions to explain the pain.

SECONDARY BENEFITS FROM BEING IN PAIN

I should not neglect to mention that psychologists/psychiatrists tell us that pain may be experienced when there is no obvious cause. Sometimes, the cause is present, but we just can’t find it. Sometimes, the presence of pain allows the avoidance of specific “undesirable” activities (work, sex, travel, physical exercise, etc.). In the latter situation, we labor to solve the wrong problem by looking for a pain source when none is going to be found. I advocate a thorough search for pain sources, but I try to also look for secondary benefits from having pain. Often the individual involved has no conscious awareness that the presence of pain is achieving another benefit in her life.

ANGER & RESENTMENT THAT RESULTS IN MUSCLE TENSION

This is probably not something that you would expect an expert on endo to be including in his blog, but I think that it may have value to a few individuals.

Anger (of any type and from any source) causes increased muscle tension and increased gastric motility amongst may other physiologic responses in the body. If there is a place in the body that is injured or inflamed, it will be particularly sensitive to surrounding increases in muscle tension. Those endo patients with GI symptoms may see their symptoms increase around times of significant anger.

Stay tuned for more on endometriosis, coming soon!

Disclaimer: any and all material(s) presented herein are offered for informational purposes only. Such material is not intended to offer or replace medical advice offered by your personal physicians or healthcare professionals. No information herein should be considered as party to any doctor/patient relationship. All contents herein are © copyright by Robert B. Albee, Jr., MD except where otherwise explicitly noted. All rights reserved. This material may not be reproduced or utilized in any form, including electronic or mechanical, photocopying, recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system except for personal or teaching use with prior permission. Thank you.

BLOG #6 – QUESTION: HOW SHOULD I FIND A TRUE EXPERT TO TREAT MY ENDOMETRIOSIS?

DSC_1686-1

Relative to most physicians who have not had gynecology-specific advanced training (such as an ‘Ob/Gyn’ residency), all gynecologists should be considered as general experts in endometriosis care, but with varying degrees of experience. Here are some hints to help you find the expert among the experts:

Start by doing your research!

  • If you know women who have been treated for ‘endo’, ask them about their experiences with specific doctors.
  • Google “‘endo’ experts” in your zip code, state, and geographic region to establish a list of possibilities.

Visit on-line ‘endo’ sites such as:

Acquaint yourself with valuable ‘endo’ advocate resources such as:

  • Nancy Peterson & Nancy’s Nook for Endometriosis on Facebook
  • Endometropolis on Facebook
  • World Endometriosis Research Foundation on Facebook
  • caseyberna.com
  • salliesarrel.com
  • EndoIreland on Facebook

Ask your regular gynecologist if he/she knows of anyone in the area specializing in treating patients with endo. Be sure that they understand that you are seeking to be treated by what we term LAPEX – Laparoscopic Excision, the gold standard, if that is appropriate for your situation.

Look for gynecologists demonstrating evidence of advanced surgical training.

  • Member of the AAGL (formerly known as the Association of Gynecologic Laparoscopists)
  • Certified as ‘ACGE” by the AAGL
  • Certified as ‘COEMIG’ (Center of Excellence in Minimally Invasive Gynecology) by Surgical Review Corporation
  • Establish a list of prospective doctors to evaluate further

Unfortunately, a broad and vastly mistaken assumption exists that all surgery for endometriosis is performed by surgeons of similar experience and skill. This completely overlooks the wide disparity that actually exists and does not address the issue of completeness in removing all disease at the time of surgery, ignoring the excellent results of truly skilled excisionists with adequate experience in recognition and total resection. Finding a true specialist can be critical.

When choosing your physician, consider the following:

  • Do not be afraid to see multiple doctors. The time and money that you spend will be rewarded in the end if your ‘endo’ is successfully treated. Traveling for appropriate ‘gold standard’ treatment is common because referral centers and/or true endo specialists are not found in every state.
  • Look for a doctor that is interested in you and will spend the time you need answering your questions. If you feel that your doctor is too busy, he/she probably is.
  • Make a list of questions that you would like answered by the doctor and/or his/her staff in order to help your selection process. See my suggested list of questions below to select the ones that you believe are appropriate for you.

Dr Albee’s list of questions intended to help you find the expert among experts:

  1. Do you prefer to treat ‘endo’ patients by surgically excising the disease – or by suppressing the disease with drug therapies?
  2. Do you believe in complete excision of all ‘endo’ in most cases?
  3. If you believe in surgical excision, do you remove all abnormal peritoneum or just what you think is ‘endo’?
  4. If you believe in surgical excision, can you do it Laparoscopically (this is ideal)?
  5. Do you send all tissue to the pathology department for evaluation and confirmation?
  6. How many patients have you treated by surgical excision in the last 6 months? (high volume is important: 0-2=small experience base, 3-12=worth considering, 13 or more=great experience and dedication)
  7. If you find invasive disease involving the urinary bladder, bowel or ureter, how do you proceed? (‘stop and refer to specialists’=acceptable, ‘stop and organize team to accomplish removal of all disease’=better, ‘proceed to treat the areas using available specialists on-call’=best)
  8. Do you provide your patients with complete record copies including operative reports, pathology reports and photographs?

Knowledge is power and when it comes to picking your doctor, deciding whether or when and which surgery is right for you, fighting for excision and adopting practices and lifestyle adjuncts that you can do for yourself as a partner in your own care, you are your own best advocate.

Stay tuned for Dr Albee’s thoughts about alternative medicine approaches, palliative measures, nutrition and lifestyle for the ‘endo’ patient!

Disclaimer: any and all material(s) presented herein are offered for informational purposes only. Such material is not intended to offer or replace medical advice offered by your personal physicians or healthcare professionals. No information herein should be considered as party to any doctor/patient relationship. All contents herein are © copyright by Robert B. Albee, Jr., MD except where otherwise explicitly noted. All rights reserved. This material may not be reproduced or utilized in any form, including electronic or mechanical, photocopying, recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system except for personal or teaching use with prior permission. Thank you.

Blog #2: My Suggested Treatment Plan

In most cases, I favor treating patients definitively (I will list the exceptions to this recommendation in following commentary).

This means that I recommend all endometriosis is completely excised from the body. Up to this point in time, the only way that I am aware of that this can be done is by surgical excision. While I favor doing this Laporoscopically (using small umbilical and accessory ports for instrument insertion), this treatment can also be done by laparotomy (open incision). The energy source used for excision is best left to the experience and confidence of the surgeon, but I use the carbon dioxide laser as my energy source (why will be the discussion of another blog; see also http://centerforendo.com/dr-albee-on-excision).
china6There is one critically important aspect of excising all disease that is often overlooked by surgeons. Subtle ‘endo’ can hide in peritoneum that looks atypical, but does not have one of the ‘classic’ appearances of ‘endo’. In order to have low recurrence rates, surgeons must not leave any disease behind. This means that the surgeon must be committed to removing abnormal/atypical peritoneum even when it does not have a ‘classical’ appearance. For more on this discussion, refer to one of my academic papers on the subject: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18262141.

Definitive treatment in my experience is the most effective treatment because it:

– Results in the longest intervals of time before retreatment is required (our data continues to indicate that 80-85% of our patients are currently free from any clinical indication of recurrent ‘endo’);
– Results in a significant improvement in ‘quality of life’ and pain reduction scores on follow-up surveys; and
– Fertility rates improve in stage 2, stage 3,and stage 4 cases after excision

The emotional burden of being told that you have an incurable disease is enormous. I do not tell patients that I am going to cure them, but I do tell them that if they have any more ‘endo,’ they will be the exception and not the rule (understanding that not all pelvic pain is the result of endometriosis and there are often comorbidities which also need to be addressed). Please note my above figure on our percentage of clinically disease-free patients after excision.

In following blogs, I will discuss the current objections to definitive treatment, and the reasons that I feel it is not more commonly used. But up next, let’s talk about ‘when I do not recommend definitive treatment.’ Stay tuned!

Disclaimer: any and all material(s) presented herein are offered for informational purposes only. Such material is not intended to offer or replace medical advice offered by your personal physicians or healthcare professionals. No information herein should be considered as party to any doctor/patient relationship. All contents herein are © copyright by Robert B. Albee, Jr., MD except where otherwise explicitly noted. All rights reserved. This material may not be reproduced or utilized in any form, including electronic or mechanical, photocopying, recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system except for personal or teaching use with prior permission. Thank you.

Blog #1 July, 2017 “The Great Treatment Debate:” first, lets define some important terms…

Let’s use two large treatment categories:

  1. Definitive Treatment
  2. Non-definitive Treatment

‘Definitive Treatment’ includes all treatments intended to completely remove all areas of endometriosis.

  • Laparotomy with excision of all areas (using the technique and energy source chosen by the surgeon)
  • Laparoscopy with excision of all areas (using the technique and energy source chosen by the surgeon)
  • Hysterectomy/Oophorectomy only if all areas of ‘endo’ are also completely removed at the same time
  • Possible future techniques using external energy sources to remove ‘endo’

‘Non-definitive treatment’ includes treatment options intended to control the disease.

  • Observation: is really not in either category, but is still a ‘non-treatment’ choice if a patient’s diagnosis is uncertain, examination is normal, and pain is easily manageable
  • Disease Suppression:
    • Simple ovulation inhibition
    • Progesterone therapy
    • Anti-estrogen therapy
    • Advanced ovulation inhibition resulting in medical castration
    • Aromatase Inhibitors
  •  Disease Reduction:
    • Laparotomy with removal of some, but not all, ‘endo’
    • Laparoscopy with removal of some, but not all, ‘endo’

The standard treatment for ‘endo’ today has not changed significantly during my professional career. This approach is predominately ‘non-definitive.’ It begins with simple suppressive treatments, using stronger suppressive treatments when pain or infertility persists, and may include surgery with some disease removal, then ultimately leads to hysterectomy when the disease remains uncontrolled.

Sadly, I see many of these hysterectomized patients who actually needed only to have their ‘endo’ actually removed – excised – to achieve a satisfactory quality of life. Even worse, if all ‘endo’ is not removed at the time of hysterectomy, pain may continue despite the absence of the uterus or even ovaries if the patient is placed on hormone replacement (basically a good idea in the castrated woman of premenopausal age).

Why has the non-definitive treatment of the disease remained standard? Blog #2 will continue this discussion, along with my approach to treatment. Stay tuned!

Disclaimer: any and all material(s) presented herein are offered for informational purposes only. Such material is not intended to offer or replace medical advice offered by your personal physicians or healthcare professionals. No information herein should be considered as party to any doctor/patient relationship. All contents herein are © copyright by Robert B. Albee, Jr., MD except where otherwise explicitly noted. All rights reserved. This material may not be reproduced or utilized in any form, including electronic or mechanical, photocopying, recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system except for personal or teaching use with prior permission. Thank you.